Catastrophic Injury · TBI
California Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) Attorney
Civil trial representation for survivors and families coping with traumatic brain injury. Mild, moderate, or severe — TBI cases require careful medical and legal development.
Cases that depend on long-term costs, life-care planning, and medical authority.
Understanding traumatic brain injury
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is caused by an external force — a blow, a jolt, or a penetrating injury — that disrupts normal brain function. Severity is commonly classified using the Glasgow Coma Scale: mild (GCS 13–15), moderate (9–12), and severe (3–8). Even a mild TBI (often called a concussion) can produce lasting cognitive, emotional, and functional impairments. Severe TBI frequently requires lifetime care and produces some of the largest damages awards in personal injury litigation.
Common causes we see in California cases
- Motor vehicle and motorcycle collisions (highest single TBI cause)
- Trucking and commercial vehicle accidents
- Falls — particularly construction, elevated work, and premises liability
- Sports and recreation injuries (helmeted and non-helmeted)
- Assault and intentional torts where third-party premises liability applies
- Work-related third-party civil claims (we do not handle workers' compensation directly, but we do handle third-party civil claims)
What makes TBI cases complex
TBI cases turn on three medical-legal challenges: (1) diagnosis — mild TBI often does not appear on standard CT or MRI imaging; specialized neuropsychological testing and DTI/SPECT imaging may be required; (2) causation — defendants frequently argue the injury was pre-existing or unrelated; and (3) damages — lifetime care costs for severe TBI often exceed several million dollars and require credentialed life-care planners, vocational economists, and treating physicians to prove.
Medical case development
Proving a TBI case requires more than a hospital chart. In most serious matters we coordinate a multi-disciplinary medical workup that typically includes:
- Imaging beyond the ER films. Standard CT and conventional MRI often miss diffuse axonal injury. Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) and MR spectroscopy can detect white-matter tract damage that explains otherwise "invisible" symptoms. SPECT and PET imaging are used selectively for perfusion abnormalities.
- Neuropsychological testing. A full battery (commonly 6–8 hours, often over two days) by a board-certified neuropsychologist quantifies deficits in memory, attention, executive function, and processing speed, and objectively separates brain injury effects from mood disorder or pre-existing learning differences.
- Vestibular and ocular-motor evaluation. Concussions frequently disturb the vestibular-ocular system. VOR testing, VNG, and specialized visual tracking assessments reveal objective dysfunction that correlates with dizziness, headache, and cognitive fatigue.
- Neurology and physiatry consultation. Post-concussive symptom tracking, medication management, and functional capacity documentation build the longitudinal record a defense expert cannot easily dismiss.
- Pre-injury baseline reconstruction. School records, prior employer performance reviews, military fitness reports, SAT/ACT scores, and lay testimony from family and coworkers establish what the client was like before the injury — the foundation for every damages argument.
Common defense themes and how we counter them
TBI defense playbooks are predictable. The three most common lines of attack — and how we prepare to meet them:
- "The CT was normal, so there's no real injury." We meet this with DTI/MRS imaging, neuropsych testing, and peer-reviewed literature (Yuh, Mukherjee, Hulkower, and the TRACK-TBI collaborative) that establishes the limits of conventional imaging and the objective reality of mild TBI.
- "Symptoms are exaggerated or psychogenic." Board-certified neuropsychologists administer validity testing (TOMM, Word Memory Test, embedded validity indicators) built into the standard battery. A clean validity profile removes malingering as a defense before it starts.
- "The problems pre-existed the accident." This is where the pre-injury baseline work matters most. Transcripts, prior evaluations, employer records, and lay witnesses establish a clean line before the event — and a changed person after.
Counter-strategy is built into case selection and early medical workup, not saved for rebuttal at trial.
Life-care planning and the economic damages model
Severe TBI cases require a credentialed life-care planner (typically CLCP or CCM credentialed, often a registered nurse) working in tandem with a board-certified physiatrist and a forensic economist. The life-care plan itemizes every projected cost category over the client's remaining life expectancy — medications, attendant care, residential or assisted-living needs, equipment, home modifications, transportation, periodic rehabilitation, and case management. A forensic economist then present-values the plan using Department of Labor and BLS data.
For a working-age client with severe TBI, a life-care plan routinely exceeds several million dollars — and that is before adding lost earning capacity, pain and suffering, and loss of consortium. This is why TBI cases can justify the investment in truly rigorous medical proof: the damages are genuinely large, but only when the proof is there.
Applicable California law
California's general negligence law applies (Cal. Civ. Code § 1714); product liability where a defective product caused the injury (Soule v. General Motors and Barker v. Lull progeny); premises liability (Rowland v. Christian); and wrongful death where TBI is fatal (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 377.60). The two-year statute of limitations for personal injury claims (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 335.1) generally applies, but tolling rules — including tolling for incapacity (Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 352) — can extend the deadline.
Damages in TBI cases
- Past and future medical expenses (often the largest damage element)
- Lost earnings and lost earning capacity
- Life-care plan costs (residential care, supervision, therapy)
- Pain and suffering / loss of enjoyment of life
- Loss of consortium for spouses
- Punitive damages where conduct was malicious or oppressive (Cal. Civ. Code § 3294)
Common Questions
My CT scan was normal. Do I still have a TBI case?
Possibly. Mild TBI frequently does not appear on standard CT imaging. Diagnosis often requires neuropsychological testing, comprehensive symptom evaluation, and sometimes specialized imaging like DTI or SPECT. A normal CT scan is not the end of the analysis.
How is a TBI case valued?
Valuation depends on severity, prognosis, age, earning capacity, life-care needs, and applicable insurance limits. Severe TBI cases requiring lifetime care can produce damages in the millions. Mild TBI cases are valued more modestly but can still be substantial when symptoms are well-documented and persistent.
What if the TBI is from an accident that happened years ago?
California's general statute of limitations for personal injury is two years. However, tolling for incapacity, late discovery of the injury's true severity, or a deferred onset of symptoms can sometimes extend this. Each case is fact-specific.
Will I have to relive the trauma to bring a claim?
Civil litigation involves discovery and may require depositions and trial testimony. We work with clients at their pace, coordinate with treating providers, and prepare carefully for any required testimony. Settlement before trial is the norm in most cases.
For a confidential review of your case:
“The cases we take are cases where the medical proof can carry the damages. That is not rhetoric — it is the test every file gets at intake.”
Law Offices of David L. Milligan · Fresno, California
Important: This page is provided for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Submitting an inquiry does not create an attorney–client relationship; that relationship is formed only by a written agreement signed after we evaluate the matter for conflicts and merit. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Statutory citations are illustrative; the legal framework applicable to a specific case depends on the facts. The Law Offices of David L. Milligan is licensed in California.